Showing posts with label India. Show all posts
Showing posts with label India. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 10, 2011

Real Estate – A Fast Path to U.S. Green Card

Philip Seagraves, MBA, MSRE
In 1990, the US Congress passed legislation that was part of the Immigration Act of 1990 which was aimed at increasing US jobs through foreign investment. The law created a new visa type, the EB-5 which provides an accelerated method for foreign persons to achieve permanent, legal residence in the US. The EB-5 process results in a green card for the foreign investor as well as his spouse and children making all eligible to work in the US and attend US schools. Many forms of investment in nearly every imaginable industry are eligible for consideration under this visa program as long as they result in at least 10 jobs and meet minimum dollar investment levels depending upon the location of the investment.
Many foreign investors participate in large cooperative projects through partnerships, limited liability companies, and those sponsored by Regional Centers throughout the US. The regulations require the investor to be involved in the management of the project. However, the management requirement can be somewhat minimal as the investor is permitted to be involved in “management or policy making.” By this definition, even limited partners may be considered engaged in the business so long as the partnership is properly formed and meets the definitions under the Uniform Limited Partnership Act. Structured investments through Regional Centers are a popular option for those who do not wish to be involved in the day-to-day activities of the business.
An important risk for relatively detached, remote investors in an EB-5 project is the potential for a complete loss of capital in an unsuccessful project. Investment in a service business or other enterprise with largely intellectual, non-tangible assets presents the investor with little recourse in the event of poor performance by the active management or simple business cycle downturns. One alternative that many EB-5 investors turn to is investment with a heavy real estate component which provides a tangible, hard asset element to the project. If a project does not succeed, the investor in a real estate related project will often be left with the land or building component of the investment which likely has some alternate use or liquidation value.
Some examples of real estate related projects that have been used for EB-5 investment include hotels, shopping centers, and even agricultural enterprises. These projects provide the foreign investor with some sense of comfort knowing that their capital is going, at least in part, toward real assets with a measurable market value and some future value regardless of the success of the job creating component of the project. This added element of security, combined with relatively low real estate prices in the US have served to increase interest and activity in real estate related EB-5 projects and the Regional Centers offering real estate projects.
Upon approval of an applicant’s original request on form I-529, the Petition for an Alien Entrepreneur, the individual, spouse and children receive a conditional green card for two years. During the last 90 days of the conditional period, they must document the completed investment as well as the job creation promised when applying and file form I-829, the Petition by Entrepreneur to Remove Conditions. When the conditions are removed, the investor and family are granted permanent residence status permitting free movement, work, and enrollment in US schools.
In summary, individuals seeking permanent residence in the US may leverage a relatively safe, secure investment in real estate to bypass the quotas, backlogs and sponsorship requirements of other permanent residence and citizenship approaches. Upon approval of the original form I-529, the , individuals and their families immediately are granted a conditional green card with conditions completely removed during the first two years following the investment. Utilizing real estate as the key element of the investment provides the investor with the assurance that their capital is being put to use in purchasing something of true, lasting value. Certainly, real estate can lose value like any other investment. However, land and improvements such as buildings provide a significant backstop against an entire loss of capital in a foreign land. 

The Opinion Editor Philip Seagraves, MBA, MSRE is an Academic Consultant to realism.IN. He is a Visiting Lecturer at Mississippi State University. Philip helps international investors with real estate acquisition in the United States and can be reached at philip [AT] chanpart [DOT] com.

Wednesday, June 29, 2011

Property Taxes in India

Data Source: Mathur, Om Prakash; Thakur, Debdulal & Rajadhyaksha, Nilesh; "Urban Property Tax Potential in India"; National institute of Public Finance & Policy; July 2009

A team of researchers at the National Institute of Public Finance and Policy, New Delhi with support from Professor Roy Bahl (Andrew Young School of Policy Studies, Georgia State University, Atlanta) conducted a study using the data of 36 large municipal corporations to estimate the potential of property taxes and suggest how that potential might be realized. The study provides an incisive commentary on how the property taxation works in various parts of India. In addition, the report also provides useful data, analysis and information related to property taxation. In particular, analysis of productivity and performance of property taxes have been discussed. In the end, the study suggests policy strategies on how to tap the untapped property taxation potentials.
At realism.IN, we provide some basic graphs derived from the data published in the report.

Per Capita Property Tax in Selected Indian Cities (2006-07)
(Click on the images to view them in better quality)

Property Tax Demand and Collection in Indian Cities (2004-07)
(Click on the images to view them in better quality)


Property Tax Collected as a Percent of Demanded in Indian Cities (2004-07)
(Click on the images to view them in better quality)


Thursday, June 16, 2011

realism.IN is Incorporated!

New Delhi June 15' 2011
The Directors of realism.IN™ are pleased to announce the incorporation of realism.IN™ ('the company') as 'Realism Real Estate Consultancy Private Limited'. The incorporation is given in Delhi under the Companies Act, 1956. We shall continue to maintain the "realism.IN™ " short name for our branding purposes.

We would take this opportunity to congratulate all our clients, consultants, subscribers and service providers on the incorporation of realism.IN™ . Since the inception of our company last year, we have received wholehearted support from the industry and the academia in India. With time our commitment towards excellence and enrichment of product volume has only strenghthened.

About realism.IN
realism.IN™ is a partnership of academicians and industry professionals striving to provide high quality knowledge backbone to the real estate industry in India. realism.IN™ is the first of its kind eLearning content provider to group customers (educational institutions, corporates and organizations) offering real estate education deeply embedded in the Indian context and reinforced by the U.S. pedagogical principles. In addition, realism.IN™ conducts high quality research independently and for clients. realism.IN™ also publishes focused white papers and OpEds to its subscribers and clients. More at http://www.realism.in

Sunday, May 22, 2011

The Curious Case of Indian Real Estate

The Paradox of Manpower Resources

"If we keep doing what we are doing, then we will keep getting what we are getting":
-David Thornburg, a noted American author 
Our recent primary study of real estate developers across India suggests that they, on average, intend to triple their development activity within a year. For sure, they see a clear demand for real property in their respective markets. More importantly, their intentions to triple their space production also means that they are confident to capture that share of the market.

This made us wonder about the dynamics of their manpower. In other words, we wanted to see how sensitive the size of their manpower is given a larger market they get to serve every passing year. Since we do not have any time-series data on the companies, we conducted a cross sectional analysis (i.e. we looked at our sample of companies at a given time rather than analyzing them over time). Our approach was simple: correlate the company's size with its manpower size as was reported in our study. The results are encouraging but not at par with the growth in demand! With each year of increase in the company age, the Indian real estate companies in our sample reported to have increased less than 85% of the man power.  Now, compare this manpower growth (<85%) with the companies' product growth (>300%) and you will get a picture of how critical the dearth of skill in Indian real estate is. Thus, although the opportunities triple, the manpower does not even double itself.
Variation of Company size with respect to Company Age | realism.IN Research


We argue that the dearth of skilled manpower is a far more serious problem than what it looks like. It points out a dire need for specialized real estate expertise the absence of which has made Indian real estate what it is: unorganized, opaque, volatile and, above all, unpredictable.
In our paper titled "10 Reasons Why Indian Real Estate Needs Specialists", we have uncovered many facets of this issue in detail.
In our follow up to this article, we will present the volatility pattern in the publicly traded realty sector of India. We examine the connection between the capital markets of Indian real estate and the underlying property market fundamentals. The question then arises is do we understand these fundamentals? More importantly, have we developed those fundamentals? Well, in spite of being one of the largest real estate markets in the world, we do not have many dedicated research/educational institutions that focus on the development of fundamental knowledge of real estate. It is a challenging task. First, we need to have institutions which have serious interest in developing the right, localized knowledge of real estate. Second, we need robust mechanisms to disseminate the knowledge sustainably. In order to fill the gap, private research and educational institutions should be encouraged and funded; not only by the government; but also by the private sector. In addition, the public institutions need to partner with the private ones to uplift the standard of real estate research and education in India.

Real Estate was established as an independent research & educational discipline in the United States during 1800s and in the UK in early 1900s. The understanding of real estate sector in these nations is superior, sophisticated and forward looking. Moreover, there has been an increasingly higher push on differentiating the  real estate assets from other financial assets. In India, we keep treating real estate as just another type of financial assets. That is why, we have failed to identify the need for regulatory changes in this sector. We face major challenges in establishing the REIT system as we lack the insights pertaining to their implications. Our secondary mortgage markets are embarrassingly smaller compared to an implied primary market. We continue to treat real estate as a subsidiary of either finance or infrastructure or engineering or design sectors (without being sure of which one of these does the realty sector actually belong to).

Some educational institutions and professional bodies (which can be counted on finger tips) have dared to come forward and fill the gaps and transform the realty sector. At realism.IN, we are committed to participate in the transformation.




Prashant Das, the opinion editor is a partner at realism.IN

Wednesday, March 23, 2011

Sharpe Ratio of Bombay Stock Exchange Indices

Correlation of BSE Realty Index with other Indices

Index Levels

Bombay Stock Exchange Indices | Weekly Returns

Bombay Stock Exchange Indices | Conditional Volatilities

Bombay Stock Exchange Indices | Risk Adjusted Returns

Sunday, March 13, 2011

10 Reasons:Why Indian Real Estate needs Specialist

Exclusive White Paper from realism.IN

Is real estate an independent discipline or a subset of finance, marketing, construction or management? Is real estate a science, applied science or engineering? Why should Indians specialize in real estate? realism.IN team brings a global perspective to this debate in this exclusive white paper. A must read for real estate professionals, educators, policy makers, and aspirants.

Is India Ready for REITs?

Exclusive White Paper from realism.IN
In spite of being a hot emerging market India has been unable to make Real Estate Investment Trust (REIT) a reality in domestic markets. What is a REIT? Why should Indian real estate be interested, if at all? How ready are we to launch this structure for real estate investment in India? Read this realism.IN white paper for answers. Also published on India China America Institute's ChindiaBiz Series.

Is India Ready for REITS (Download with registration)

5 Steps to Building an "Information-Edge" in Real Estate

Exclusive White Paper from realism.IN

Published by the Confederation of Real Estate Developers Association of India (CREDAI) and authored by realism.IN, this article provides pragmatic insights on how to get the best out of data in real estate business. Why is data collection important? How could you develop in-house capabiliities to collect and process data? How can you maximize your profits in real estate business with such data?

Tuesday, March 8, 2011

BSE Realty Index

With the First issue of realism Round-Up, we at realism.IN announce our commitment to keep you updated about Indian real estate markets: both at the Dalal Street and the Main Street. This series should provide you with fairly useful business/investment insights about the publicly traded real estate stocks in India.
What else? We also help you assess the implied volatility in the BSE Realty Index on a weekly basis. Did you know that this implied volatility is not observable; but is known to be an important factor in investment decision making? And yes, for numerous stock indices, this volatility tells a lot about future returns. So, here we go: Our analysts provide you with the implied volatility patterns extracted from their sophisticated econometric models to help you assess the risk in this index. 

Stay tuned for our upcoming issues which will also help you with some benchmark indices for comparison!

(click on the images below to get higher-quality illustrations)


Real Estate Development Indices

Click on the image to see a higher-quality illustration.  

In July 2007, the National Housing Bank (NHB) launched the first-of-its kind residential real estate index in India named as "Residex". The Residex is based on actual transaction price of real estate in the cities covered under the index. The aggregated Residex started with 5 cities: Delhi, Mumbai, Kolkata, Bangalore and Bhopal. Later, Ahmedabad, Faridabad, Chennai, Kochi, Hyderabad, Jaipur, Patna, Lucknow, Pune and Surat were added.  


Building Construction Cost Index
Click on the image to see a higher-quality illustration.  

The Construction Industry Development Council (CIDC) in India has been releasing its construction cost index (CCI) since 1998. The Index measures an overall variations in the cost of construction  of projects including buildings, roads, bridges, railway construction, dams, power plants, factories etc.  



How to interpret the graphs:  In the bar chart above, realism.IN presents you city level data sourced from the NHB and CIDC. For each city, 2007 has been assumed to be the base year rated at 100 index value. Thus, the height of the bar corresponding to a city represents the multiple by which the overall transaction prices (Residex) or the construction Cost (CCI) of the residential buildings have increased in the 2010 Q2 compared to 2007. For example, a value of 110 for New Delhi suggest that the transaction prices multiplied by 10% (i.e.110/100 minus 100 percent) with respect to 2007 prices. Similarly, a CCI of 115.25 in Chennai would imoly that the construction costs in Chennai had multipled 1.15 times since 2007 during 2010.



Sunday, January 9, 2011

So, What does realism.IN do, again???

The roads ahead
Are we really needed? This rather "classical" business plan questions has been tickling us for a while. For several reasons, though, this question has never haunted us. The rationale is simple: we have examined the need in India for what we offer; and we examined it robustly. We introduced our offerings to the most hardcore of skeptics; but got only positive vibes.
So, what are our offerings again?

Is it "Real Estate Research"?
Yes and No! Our vision for real estate research revolves around building up of the fundamental business knowledge of real estate whereas the existing body of real estate research in India focuses on building market information (which, too, is critical to the business). Some market players are doing really great job in this domain. We strengthen their work by building the "knowledge" that ensures a symbiotic relationship between all segments of Indian real estate. So, instead of making a bold claim of "paradigm shift", we offer the "reinforcement" of the existing paradigm!

Is it "eLearning"?
Well, we do mention "eLearning" on our website. But, what we offer is far beyond this rather trivializing word of 9 letters. We provide contents the likes of which have never been available in India before. Yes, we provide you the real estate knowledge that is "local" to India. We have invested tremendous resources in developing the contents for our "CompEd eLearning" offerings. So, to learn about Indian real estate, you no more need to buy the real estate books which are full of "American" and "British" concepts most of which are, perhaps, not even relevant to India. Moreover, would a case study on a British real estate financing really help you with your venture structuring in, say, Pune?

Anything Else?
Yes!!! In fact, our biggest offering is the comprehensive "Knowledge Backbone" to Indian real estate players that manifests in the offerings we just discussed. We make real estate knowledge "local" to India. We do that by blending the fundamental western knowledge of real estate in the Indian contest.

The roads ahead are not rosy. We venture into a market which is, still, to get in terms with regulations that are yet being conceived; norms that are yet to be created and temperament which is yet to start valuing the strengths of research and knowledge.
We are ready to take the challenges on. Are you? Is realism your partner for life? Just roll the dice!
Explore more about us at http://www.realism.in.